Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy something through one of them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Out of Ellie Vail’s entire best-sellers collection, one pair of earrings has more reviews than almost anything else in the catalog: the Erin Huggie Hoop Earring, priced at $60 with 83 reviews attached to it. I read through a large chunk of those reviews, plus the brand’s own materials FAQ, to see if it earns the spot.
What it’s made of
Like the rest of Ellie Vail’s catalog, the Erin Huggies start as hypoallergenic stainless steel, then get a PVD gold coating between 1.5 and 2 microns thick, according to the brand’s official FAQ. That’s a denser, more durable layer than the thin electroplating used on most fast-fashion earrings.
Because the base is stainless steel rather than brass or nickel, the huggies are built to handle sweat, showers, and swimming without the metal rusting or turning your ears green. They’re also sold in both gold and silver finishes, so the styling works either way.
What buyers are actually saying
83 reviews on a single earring style is a real sample size, not a handful of cherry-picked testimonials. One buyer, Devlin Hopper, wrote: “I truly love these earrings!! So stylish and the best part is I can leave them on days or weeks if I want to!!” That’s a common thread across Ellie Vail’s reviews generally: people wear the pieces continuously instead of taking them off for showers or workouts.
The brand-wide review pattern (4.6 out of 5 across 6,237 reviews) is worth keeping in mind here too. The most common complaint across the catalog is sizing running slightly larger than expected on bangles and rings, though huggie hoops are less prone to that issue since they don’t rely on a size chart the same way.
Fit and everyday wear
Huggie hoops sit close to the earlobe, which makes them easy to sleep in and layer under a hood or scarf without snagging. That’s part of why reviewers mention leaving them in for weeks at a time.
Ellie Vail’s FAQ does note that lotion and perfume applied near the ears will accelerate plating fade over time. If you wear these daily, keep skincare products away from the earlobe area to protect the gold finish.
How it compares
Against Ellie Vail’s own catalog, the Erin Huggies have more reviews than the Arielle Bangle, the Paola Necklace, or the Camden Choker, making them the safest first purchase if you’re new to the brand. Against a lower-priced competitor like Ezra Gems, you’re paying more but getting a thicker PVD coating and a much larger track record of reviews. I laid out that full trade-off in Ellie Vail vs Ezra Gems.
Should you buy it
If you want a hypoallergenic, water-resistant hoop with a genuinely large review base backing it up, the Erin Huggie Hoop Earring is the easiest starting point in Ellie Vail’s lineup. Keep lotion and perfume away from your ears to protect the plating, and expect to wear these continuously rather than taking them on and off.
For more on how the brand handles returns if the fit or finish isn’t right, see my returns and shipping guide. For daily care instructions, check how to care for Ellie Vail jewelry.
Keep reading: my full Ellie Vail brand review, how to pick the right Ellie Vail piece, and where to buy Ellie Vail authentically.