Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy something through one of them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
One QIY listing keeps popping up when you search for affordable strappy heels: a black stiletto sandal with a square open toe, a 3 inch heel, and a faux leather upper. It’s currently ranked #77 in Amazon’s Women’s Heeled Sandals category, which puts it well inside the top 100 of a genuinely crowded category.
I went looking for the price and star rating on this exact listing and hit a wall. Amazon blocks automated access to that data, so instead of guessing, I’m building this review around what’s actually verifiable: the stated specs, the category ranking, and how this pair stacks up against the rest of QIY’s documented lineup.
What the listing actually claims
Per the product title, this is a strappy stiletto sandal with a square open toe, a 3 inch heel, and a faux leather build, sold in black. It’s been listed since February 2025. Amazon’s search index doesn’t surface a public price or review count for this specific listing through standard tools, so I’d treat any number you see on the page itself as the only reliable source. Check it directly before you buy.
That’s a real limitation, and I’d rather flag it than fill the gap with a made-up star rating.
How it fits the rest of the QIY lineup
QIY’s official catalog on Modatope’s site includes a close cousin to this style: the Selmira Ankle Strap Sandals, a $39.99 faux leather stiletto with an open toe and a 3.15 inch heel. It’s not the same product, but the construction and price bracket give you a reasonable idea of what to expect from a QIY stiletto sandal in this category.
Across QIY’s documented sandals and heels, faux leather is the standard upper material, and stiletto heels in this range typically fall between 3 and 3.74 inches. A square open toe is common on the brand’s ankle-strap styles. Nothing about this listing’s stated specs looks out of line with the rest of the catalog.
Sizing and what to check before you order
The listing title references size 6, but Amazon shoe listings for this brand typically offer a full run. Confirm the size options on the live listing rather than assuming size 6 is the only choice.
QIY’s comparable sandals on the official site run true to a standard US 6 to 11 range. A 3 inch stiletto with an open toe tends to run slightly looser at the toe box than a closed-toe pump, so if you’re between sizes, sizing down is the more common recommendation for this heel style.
Buying through Amazon versus Modatope’s own site
This matters more than it sounds like. If you buy this listing through Amazon, your return covers under Amazon’s standard return policy for that seller, not Modatope’s site policy. Modatope’s own site charges a $6.95 restocking fee on returns and requires items to be unworn. Amazon listings can differ by seller, so check the return window on the specific listing page before you buy.
Should you buy it
If you want a square-toe stiletto sandal in the $35 to $50 territory that QIY’s comparable styles occupy, the stated specs on this listing are consistent with the rest of a catalog I could actually verify. Confirm the current price and read the seller’s specific return policy before you order, since that information isn’t something I can guarantee from here.
For the bigger picture on the brand behind this listing, see my full QIY shoes review. For help narrowing down a style, check how to choose the right QIY heels. If you want to confirm you’re buying from a legitimate listing, read where to buy authentic QIY shoes, and for keeping faux leather looking new, see QIY shoe care tips.
Keep reading: my full QIY brand review, how to choose the right QIY heels, and where to buy QIY authentically.